Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction & Tips | MLS | FootballTips.app

Columbus Crew

Columbus Crew

Home
Full Time
0 - 1
HT: 0 - 0
Saturday 12 September
New York Red Bulls

New York Red Bulls

Away
Columbus CrewTimelineNew York Red Bulls
2nd Half
Padelford D.Out: Dos Santos M.
sync_alt
66'
Cowell C.Out: Ruvalcaba J.
sync_alt
66'
Donkor R.
69'
Rodriguez S.
70'
Martinez J.Out: Tapia G.
sync_alt
71'
Sofo M.
73'
Habroune T.Out: Rodriguez S.
sync_alt
75'
Ruiz D.Out: Mehmeti A.
sync_alt
80'
Choupo-Moting E. M.Out: Hall J.
sync_alt
80'
Chambost D.Out: Gomes A.
sync_alt
83'
Thiare J.Out: Giaccone L.
sync_alt
83'
Donkor R.Assist: Harper C.
sports_soccer
89'
Nelich D.Out: Harper C.
sync_alt
90'
Mendez B.
90+1'
Moreira S.
90+2'
No statistics available for this match
auto_awesome
AI Prediction
verified Low Confidence
11.75
X4.26
23.91

Recommended Bet

cancel
Both Teams to Score
Odds: 2.62Stake: Medium (6/10)
64
Opp. Value

Key Factors

Season: Home 0.96 PPG vs Away 1.13 PPG
Recent Form (weighted): Home 1.35 PPG vs Away 0.55 PPG
Goals (venue): Home 1.42 GPG vs Away 1.17 GPG
Defense (venue): Home 1.17 conc vs Away 2.08 conc

donut_small Win Probabilities

53%
25%
23%
Columbus Crew
Draw
New York Red Bulls
payments

Value Comparison

OutcomeMarket OddsTrue Odds (AI)Value
Over 2.5 Goals1.441.80-20.2%
Under 2.5 Goals2.702.24+20.4%
Columbus Crew Win1.751.89-7.5%
Draw4.204.06+3.4%
New York RB Win4.104.44-7.7%
BTTS - Yes2.621.74+50.1%
BTTS - No1.442.34-38.5%

Fair Odds remove the bookmaker margin. Value is raw EV vs market odds; hover a badge for the edge vs fair odds.

Match Preview

Columbus Crew take on New York Red Bulls in Major League Soccer at Lower.com Field on September 13, 2026.

Sitting near the lower end of the table, Columbus Crew are 13th with 23 points, just behind New York Red Bulls who occupy 12th place with 27 points.

Recent form sees Columbus Crew having lost 83 percent of their last 6 matches, while New York Red Bulls have suffered 3 defeats in their last 6 away league games.

Under 2.5 goals have been scored in 4 of New York Red Bulls' previous 6 matches, highlighting a tendency for lower-scoring affairs in their recent outings.

Our algorithm points to under 2.5 goals scored in this match.

Columbus Crew were unable to contain Tai Baribo on Thursday as his first-half brace set Laurent Courtois' side on course for a 2-1 defeat at Audi Field. This weekend's hosts have lost six of their last seven matches in all competitions heading into gameweek 25.

New York Red Bulls had no answer for Los Angeles FC last time out, suffering a 2-0 defeat on the road at BMO Stadium on Thursday. Michael Bradley's men have failed to win any of their last six MLS matches, picking up just two points during this period.

Lineups

Lineup Predictions & Ratings

Columbus Crew

Starting 11
-Patrick Schulte
GK6.43
-Steven Moreira
DC6.29
-Sean Zawadzki
DC6.64
-Malte Amundsen
DC6.71
-Brooks Lennon
DML6.42
-Tarun Karumanchi
MC6.46
-Dylan Chambost
MC6.48
-Mohamed Farsi
DMR6.66
-Taha Habroune
AMC6.79
-Brais Méndez
AMC6.81
-Josef Martínez
FW6.21

New York Red Bulls

Starting 11
-Ethan Horvath
GK6.55
-Devin Padelford
DL6.08
-Julián Bazán
DC6.95
-Dylan Nealis
DC6.58
-Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
DR6.43
-Emil Forsberg
MC6.52
-Sekou Kone
MC6.05
-Mohammed Sofo
MC6.23
-Dennis Nelich
FWL6.28
-Eric Choupo-Moting
FW6.27
-Jorge Ruvalcaba
FWR6.59
Ratings based on player performance in recent matches

compareTeam Comparison

Based on 5 / 24 matches
Columbus CrewvsNew York Red Bulls
1.60Goals / Match1.33
0.20Conceded / Match2.00
3Clean Sheets2
51.2%Possession %53.3%
82.2%Pass Accuracy %84.2%

radarTeam Profile

Columbus Crew
New York Red Bulls
AttackDefensePossessionEfficiencyCreativityDiscipline
sports_soccer
29Attack42
shield
73Defense30
swap_horiz
53Possession63
gps_fixed
56Efficiency64
auto_fix_high
37Creativity59
gavel
54Discipline44

sports_soccerGoals & Scoring

8Goals Scored32
1Goals Conceded48
3Clean Sheets2
0Penalty Goals1

gps_fixedShooting

45Total Shots316

swap_horizPassing & Possession

51.2%Avg Possession53.3%
1,692Total Passes11,719
82.2%Pass Accuracy84.2%

shieldDefending

156Interceptions213
11Saves81
48.9%Duels Won46.4%

gavelDiscipline

49Fouls288
12Yellow Cards49
0Red Cards2
8Offsides31

analyticsOther

17Corners139
40Successful Dribbles184

Statistical Comparison

Columbus CrewMetricNew York Red Bulls
32
Goals
30
20
Assists
23
6.5
Average Ratings
6.4
27.2
Average Age
23.5
180.5
Average Height (cm)
180.8
1
Shots pg
0.8
45%
Aerial Duel Success
48%
0.4
Dribbles pg
0.6
1.2
Tackles pg
1

League Standings Context

For Columbus Crew

PosTeamPWDLPts
12New York Red Bulls24761127
13Columbus Crew24651323
14Atlanta United24641422

For New York Red Bulls

PosTeamPWDLPts
11DC United23610728
12New York Red Bulls24761127
13Columbus Crew24651323

Advanced Stats (Avg per match)

53.1/ 99.4
Dangerous Attacks
53.4/ 109.0
36.0%
Shots on Target
37.0%
11.9
Total Shots
13.1
58.0%
Possession
54.0%

Team Performance (Avg)

1.6
Goals Scored / Match
1.4
1.6
Goals Conceded / Match
1.9

Head-to-Head Summary

2
Columbus Crew Wins
33%
2
Draws
33%
2
New York Red Bulls Wins
33%
Total H2H Matches: 6

Recent Form Stats

MarketColumbus CrewNew York Red Bulls
Over 1.5 Goals
94%29/31
74%23/31
Over 2.5 Goals
74%23/31
48%15/31
Both Teams to Score
74%23/31
58%18/31
* Based on last 31 matches

Past Matches

Last 6: Columbus Crew

Us1
Columbus Crew
3 - 0
Colorado Rapids
Us1
Columbus Crew
1 - 3
New England Revolution
Us1
Columbus Crew
1 - 2
Montreal Impact
LC
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
UNAM Pumas
LC
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
Pachuca CF
LC
Columbus Crew
3 - 1
Club Atlas

Home Games: Columbus Crew

Us1
Columbus Crew
3 - 0
Colorado Rapids
Us1
Columbus Crew
1 - 3
New England Revolution
Us1
Columbus Crew
1 - 2
Montreal Impact
LC
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
UNAM Pumas
LC
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
Pachuca CF
LC
Columbus Crew
3 - 1
Club Atlas

Last 6: New York Red Bulls

Us1
Los Angeles FC
2 - 0
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Seattle Sounders
0 - 0
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Atlanta United
2 - 1
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Philadelphia Union
3 - 1
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Sporting Kansas City
1 - 2
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Chicago Fire
1 - 3
New York Red Bulls

Away Games: New York Red Bulls

Us1
Los Angeles FC
2 - 0
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Seattle Sounders
0 - 0
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Atlanta United
2 - 1
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Philadelphia Union
3 - 1
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Sporting Kansas City
1 - 2
New York Red Bulls
Us1
Chicago Fire
1 - 3
New York Red Bulls

history Recent Form

Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
1.4 GPG
W
L
L
D
W
New York Red BullsNew York Red Bulls
1.0 GPG
L
D
L
L
W

group Head to Head

PL13 May 2026
New York RB
3-2
Columbus Crew
PL18 Oct 2025
Columbus Crew
3-1
New York RB
PL30 Aug 2025
New York RB
0-0
Columbus Crew
PL3 Nov 2024
New York RB
2-2
Columbus Crew
PL29 Oct 2024
Columbus Crew
0-1
New York RB
58%
Over 2.5 Goals
67%
Both Team Score

Head-to-Head Detailed

Over 1.5 Goals
84%
36 / 43 matches
Over 2.5 Goals
58%
25 / 43 matches
Over 3.5 Goals
35%
15 / 43 matches
Both Teams to Score
67%
29 / 43 matches
Columbus Crew CS
19%
Clean Sheets
New York Red Bulls CS
19%
Clean Sheets

Recent Matches

13 May 2026
New York RB
3 - 2
Columbus Crew
18 Oct 2025
Columbus Crew
3 - 1
New York RB
30 Aug 2025
New York RB
0 - 0
Columbus Crew
3 Nov 2024
New York RB
2 - 2
Columbus Crew
29 Oct 2024
Columbus Crew
0 - 1
New York RB
19 Oct 2024
New York RB
2 - 3
Columbus Crew
16 Mar 2024
Columbus Crew
3 - 0
New York RB
1 Jul 2023
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York RB
18 Mar 2023
New York RB
2 - 1
Columbus Crew
1 Oct 2022
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York RB
20 Mar 2022
New York RB
1 - 1
Columbus Crew
23 Oct 2021
Columbus Crew
1 - 2
New York RB

Current Form Comparison

Form (Overall)
Columbus Crew
1.42
Form (Overall)
New York Red Bulls
1.00

Columbus Crew is +42% better in terms of Points Per Game

Columbus Crew
3 - 0
Colorado Rapids
Columbus Crew
1 - 3
New England Revolution
Columbus Crew
1 - 2
Montreal Impact
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
Pumas UNAM
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
Pachuca
Los Angeles FC
2 - 0
New York RB
Seattle Sounders
0 - 0
New York RB
Atlanta United FC
2 - 1
New York RB
Philadelphia Union
3 - 1
New York RB
Sporting KC
1 - 2
New York RB

Subscribe for Betting Tips

Get exclusive predictions delivered to your inbox.

No spam, unsubscribe at any time.