New York City vs Columbus Crew Prediction & Tips | MLS | FootballTips.app
auto_awesome
AI Prediction
verified Medium Confidence
12.47
X3.53
22.65
Recommended Bet
Away Win
Stake: Medium (6/10)
60
Opp. Value
Key Factors
Season: Home 1.09 PPG vs Away 1.09 PPG
Recent Form (weighted): Home 0.20 PPG vs Away 1.45 PPG
Goals (venue): Home 2.29 GPG vs Away 1.80 GPG
Defense (venue): Home 1.86 conc vs Away 2.00 conc
donut_small Win Probabilities
31%
27%
42%
New York City
Draw
Columbus Crew
Lineups
Lineup Predictions & Ratings
New York City
Starting 11
7Nicolás Fernández
CF7.91
2Nico Cavallo
0.60
10Maxi Moralez
CAM7.39
21Aiden O'Neill
CDM6.95
26Agustin Ojeda
6.84
88Malachi Jones
6.49
5Kai Clifton Trewin
6.88
13Thiago Martins
CB6.79
19Strahinja Tanasijević
CB1.76
34Raul Gustavo Pereira Bicalho
CB6.18
49Freese Matthew
GK6.94
Substitutes
17Hannes Wolf
RW6.82
8Andrés Perea
CDM6.94
29Maximo Augusto Carrizo Ballesteros
0.62
32Jonathan Shore
2.41
55Keaton Parks
CDM6.77
87Arnau Farnós Olive
3.24
99Seymour Garfield-Reid
1.77
-Tomás Romero
Columbus Crew
Starting 11
10Diego Rossi
LW7.01
27Maximilian Arfsten (Injured)
7.21
7Dylan Chambost
CM7.07
8Dániel Gazdag
CAM4.27
16Taha Habroune
7.17
25Sean Zawadzki
6.80
30Hugo Picard
6.12
4Rudy Camacho
CB6.83
18Malte Amundsen
LB6.94
31Steven Moreira
RB6.64
28Patrick Schulte
GK6.61
Substitutes
90Nəriman Axundzadə
CF2.45
-Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
14Amar Sejdic
1.89
17Sekou Tidiany Bangoura
4.76
46Chase Adams
2Marcelo Herrera
RB6.19
21Yevgen Cheberko
CB1.40
23Mohamed Farsi
3.25
-Nicholas George Hagen Godoy
Ratings based on player performance in recent matches
history Recent Form
New York CityL
L
D
L
L
Columbus CrewL
W
W
L
D
group Head to Head
PL18 Sept 2025
3-2
PL22 Mar 2025
0-0
PL1 Sept 2024
4-2
PL17 Aug 2024
1-1
PL15 Jun 2024
2-3
65%
Over 2.5 Goals
77%
Both Team Score
Head-to-Head Detailed
Over 1.5 Goals
85%
22 / 26 matches
Over 2.5 Goals
65%
17 / 26 matches
Over 3.5 Goals
50%
13 / 26 matches
Both Teams to Score
77%
20 / 26 matches
New York City CS
19%
Clean Sheets
Columbus Crew CS
8%
Clean Sheets
Recent Matches
18 Sept 2025
New York City
3 - 2
Columbus Crew
22 Mar 2025
Columbus Crew
0 - 0
New York City
1 Sept 2024
Columbus Crew
4 - 2
New York City
17 Aug 2024
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
New York City
15 Jun 2024
New York City
2 - 3
Columbus Crew
9 Jul 2023
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
New York City
17 Jun 2023
New York City
1 - 1
Columbus Crew
7 Aug 2022
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
New York City
15 May 2022
New York City
2 - 0
Columbus Crew
31 Jul 2021
New York City
4 - 1
Columbus Crew
18 Jul 2021
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York City
23 May 2021
New York City
1 - 2
Columbus Crew
Current Form Comparison
Form (Overall)
1.09
Form (Overall)
1.09
Both teams have equal form.
New York City
0 - 2
DC United
Montreal Impact
1 - 0
New York City
New York City
4 - 4
FC Cincinnati
New York City
1 - 2
Charlotte
Vancouver Whitecaps
2 - 0
New York City
Columbus Crew
2 - 3
Minnesota United
Columbus Crew
2 - 0
Philadelphia Union
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
LA Galaxy
New England Revolution
2 - 1
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
Orlando City
auto_awesome
AI Prediction
verified Medium Confidence
12.47
X3.53
22.65
Recommended Bet
Away Win
Stake: Medium (6/10)
60
Opp. Value
Key Factors
Season: Home 1.09 PPG vs Away 1.09 PPG
Recent Form (weighted): Home 0.20 PPG vs Away 1.45 PPG
Goals (venue): Home 2.29 GPG vs Away 1.80 GPG
Defense (venue): Home 1.86 conc vs Away 2.00 conc
Lineups
Lineup Predictions & Ratings
New York City
Starting 11
7Nicolás Fernández
CF7.91
2Nico Cavallo
0.60
10Maxi Moralez
CAM7.39
21Aiden O'Neill
CDM6.95
26Agustin Ojeda
6.84
88Malachi Jones
6.49
5Kai Clifton Trewin
6.88
13Thiago Martins
CB6.79
19Strahinja Tanasijević
CB1.76
34Raul Gustavo Pereira Bicalho
CB6.18
49Freese Matthew
GK6.94
Substitutes
17Hannes Wolf
RW6.82
8Andrés Perea
CDM6.94
29Maximo Augusto Carrizo Ballesteros
0.62
32Jonathan Shore
2.41
55Keaton Parks
CDM6.77
87Arnau Farnós Olive
3.24
99Seymour Garfield-Reid
1.77
-Tomás Romero
Columbus Crew
Starting 11
10Diego Rossi
LW7.01
27Maximilian Arfsten (Injured)
7.21
7Dylan Chambost
CM7.07
8Dániel Gazdag
CAM4.27
16Taha Habroune
7.17
25Sean Zawadzki
6.80
30Hugo Picard
6.12
4Rudy Camacho
CB6.83
18Malte Amundsen
LB6.94
31Steven Moreira
RB6.64
28Patrick Schulte
GK6.61
Substitutes
90Nəriman Axundzadə
CF2.45
-Cesar Ruvalcaba Perez
14Amar Sejdic
1.89
17Sekou Tidiany Bangoura
4.76
46Chase Adams
2Marcelo Herrera
RB6.19
21Yevgen Cheberko
CB1.40
23Mohamed Farsi
3.25
-Nicholas George Hagen Godoy
Ratings based on player performance in recent matches
history Recent Form
New York CityL
L
D
L
L
Columbus CrewL
W
W
L
D
Head-to-Head Detailed
Over 1.5 Goals
85%
22 / 26 matches
Over 2.5 Goals
65%
17 / 26 matches
Over 3.5 Goals
50%
13 / 26 matches
Both Teams to Score
77%
20 / 26 matches
New York City CS
19%
Clean Sheets
Columbus Crew CS
8%
Clean Sheets
Recent Matches
18 Sept 2025
New York City
3 - 2
Columbus Crew
22 Mar 2025
Columbus Crew
0 - 0
New York City
1 Sept 2024
Columbus Crew
4 - 2
New York City
17 Aug 2024
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
New York City
15 Jun 2024
New York City
2 - 3
Columbus Crew
9 Jul 2023
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
New York City
17 Jun 2023
New York City
1 - 1
Columbus Crew
7 Aug 2022
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
New York City
15 May 2022
New York City
2 - 0
Columbus Crew
31 Jul 2021
New York City
4 - 1
Columbus Crew
18 Jul 2021
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York City
23 May 2021
New York City
1 - 2
Columbus Crew
donut_small Win Probabilities
31%
27%
42%
New York City
Draw
Columbus Crew
group Head to Head
PL18 Sept 2025
3-2
PL22 Mar 2025
0-0
PL1 Sept 2024
4-2
PL17 Aug 2024
1-1
PL15 Jun 2024
2-3
65%
Over 2.5 Goals
77%
Both Team Score
Current Form Comparison
Form (Overall)
1.09
Form (Overall)
1.09
Both teams have equal form.
New York City
0 - 2
DC United
Montreal Impact
1 - 0
New York City
New York City
4 - 4
FC Cincinnati
New York City
1 - 2
Charlotte
Vancouver Whitecaps
2 - 0
New York City
Columbus Crew
2 - 3
Minnesota United
Columbus Crew
2 - 0
Philadelphia Union
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
LA Galaxy
New England Revolution
2 - 1
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
Orlando City
Weekly Newsletter
Subscribe for Betting Tips
Get exclusive predictions delivered to your inbox.
Join our community of smart bettors. Get exclusive predictions, value picks, and statistical analysis delivered straight to your inbox.
Free Weekly Tips
Value Opportunities